Search found 87 matches

Go to advanced search

by Elphiel
Jul 16 2017 05:10
Forum: Rules & FAQ
Topic: Let's Contact GW!
Replies: 130
Views: 7235

Re: Let's Contact GW!

The thing is not about IF there is an answer. Its about which of many possible answers is the correct one, or better; Wich of the answers is the answer GW had in mind at the moment they wrote them into the books. That is where all theses discussions come from. We try to find out, what the intention ...
by Elphiel
Jul 14 2017 03:35
Forum: General Discussion
Topic: 8th Edition - Rise of the Shield Generator?
Replies: 4
Views: 534

8th Edition - Rise of the Shield Generator?

Hi there! First with all the new 8th Edition Topics i could have missed it, so excuse me if I bring up an old Topic but here we go. After about 3-4 Games in the new Edition, I am very disappointed about what the Tau army has become. Besides the well known problems inside our own units I want to shif...
by Elphiel
Jul 14 2017 06:38
Forum: Rules & FAQ
Topic: Let's Contact GW!
Replies: 130
Views: 7235

Re: Let's Contact GW!

Agree. Awesome collection of current rule oddities. Keep it that detailed! The main reason why these questions come up is because the rules are not written precise or detailed enough. Solving this by asking questions the same simplified way wont help.
by Elphiel
Jul 12 2017 10:30
Forum: Rules & FAQ
Topic: Pathfinder Vanguard?
Replies: 42
Views: 1938

Re: Pathfinder Vanguard?

I think the best solution to all these issues would be to simply get rid of all that "form a seperate unit"-part for infantry and battlesuit units. For me it appears that someone simply copy and paste that wording from Drone entries of Vehicles datasheets, where they are able to disembark/...
by Elphiel
Jul 10 2017 03:14
Forum: General Discussion
Topic: New 8th FAQ
Replies: 254
Views: 17417

Re: New 8th FAQ

RAI would be completely otherwise. If the intend was, that Longstrike keeps his 2+ BS even if he moved, he would get a special rule especially for that, like Markerdrone for example. The rule says "...other friendly ...". Other is the important part here. The Rule is Longstrikes equivalent...
by Elphiel
Jul 09 2017 04:11
Forum: Rules & FAQ
Topic: Shieldline rule and dice roll rules.
Replies: 12
Views: 776

Re: Shieldline rule and dice roll rules.

I believe the Shieldline Rules together with a lot of other new 8th Edition Tau Rules are the Result of ppl converting the 7th Edition Unit Stats over to the 8Th Edition by simply using the old Datasheets as starting Point without even looking into the Fluff about a specific unit. In the old Edition...
by Elphiel
Jun 30 2017 04:02
Forum: General Discussion
Topic: Tigershark AX-1-0 FW FAQ
Replies: 29
Views: 2005

Re: Tigershark AX-1-0 FW FAQ

Keep in mind that the whole lower compartment of the TS F-B is removed and replaced with additional power supply for the AX 1-0 Railguns. So The Railgun upgrade comes with its own dedicated power supply separate from the main power supply for flight.
by Elphiel
Jun 24 2017 01:14
Forum: Tau Tactics
Topic: An interesting application of Longstrike's hull shape and terrain.
Replies: 39
Views: 2859

Re: An interesting application of Longstrike's hull shape and terrain.

I took a look inside the german rulebook. and here the wording is better to understand. 'Within' is better translated with words meaning 'inside'. So the sentence is meant like "a unit entirely on or entirely within any terrain feature".
by Elphiel
Jun 24 2017 08:09
Forum: Tau Tactics
Topic: An interesting application of Longstrike's hull shape and terrain.
Replies: 39
Views: 2859

Re: An interesting application of Longstrike's hull shape and terrain.

I think the question is, if the advanced terrain rules replace the general terrain and cover criteria from the core rules or if they are add to that rules.
If they replace the cover rules, it would make terrain rules solid again. If not we come to all these interpretation problems we have now.
by Elphiel
Jun 24 2017 07:56
Forum: Rules & FAQ
Topic: Tidewall and Embarked Models
Replies: 12
Views: 596

Re: Tidewall and Embarked Models

:edit: got something wrong. You are right. AP-3 and better weapons di eliminate the "Tidewall Field" special rule. Because applying modifiers means in the new edition to actually turn the dice and therefore changing the actual diceroll itself instead of giving a result with the diceroll as...
by Elphiel
Jun 24 2017 07:39
Forum: Tau Tactics
Topic: An interesting application of Longstrike's hull shape and terrain.
Replies: 39
Views: 2859

Re: An interesting application of Longstrike's hull shape and terrain.

Hm... i also still disagree with the "within" part. For me the Tank touching the building is not within the terrain feature.

Here is my interpretation based on a side view instead on top, to make a bit more clear.

Image
by Elphiel
Jun 24 2017 07:05
Forum: Rules & FAQ
Topic: Stimulant injector + sense of stone?
Replies: 11
Views: 787

Re: Stimulant injector + sense of stone?

Hm... i still think, its problematic. With the 8th Edition we have to watch out because a wound is not the same as damage and wounds is also the word for the hitpoints of a model. So the question here is, if the SI ans SoS rules apply for the wound like in Step 3 in "4. Resolve Attacks" on...
by Elphiel
Jun 24 2017 06:42
Forum: Rules & FAQ
Topic: Tidewall and Embarked Models
Replies: 12
Views: 596

Re: Tidewall and Embarked Models

Thats not quite right. Even if someone uses AP-3 weapons we can still throw for reflects because in 8th edition, modifiers apply after your roll. So we throw our save -> on a 6 it is reflected -> apply modifiers (6-3=3) -> check that modified save with the Sv value in the Dataslate (3 is not 4+) -> ...
by Elphiel
Jun 23 2017 06:14
Forum: Rules & FAQ
Topic: Stimulant injector + sense of stone?
Replies: 11
Views: 787

Re: Stimulant injector + sense of stone?

Interesting. Stimulant Injector talking specifically about "suffers a wound" while Sense of Stone talking specifically about "suffers an unsaved wound" So the flowchart would be: get hit -> get wound -> check SI -> if SI fails roll Sv -> if Sv fails roll 'Sense of Stone' -> if So...
by Elphiel
Jun 23 2017 04:41
Forum: General Discussion
Topic: 8th Ed FORGEWORLD Tau
Replies: 184
Views: 16336

Re: 8th Ed FORGEWORLD Tau

Elphiel, are you perhaps thinking of the new AX-5-2 Barracuda, which has Cyclic Ion Blasters as potential replacements to the Long Barrel Burst Cannon? Because the Barracuda appears to have kept that option. Or was the new Tigershark rumored to have that option as well? I might have missed that. I ...
by Elphiel
Jun 23 2017 04:06
Forum: General Discussion
Topic: 8th Ed FORGEWORLD Tau
Replies: 184
Views: 16336

Re: 8th Ed FORGEWORLD Tau

What i think is a bit weird is, that in the new Tigershark Fighter-Bomber, the 14 gun drones are not included in the point cost anymore. No more 14 gundrone squads as a unit of tactical drones has a maximum of 12 models. Sure we can pick two squads but its still odd. Also we have to pay for them ext...
by Elphiel
Jun 22 2017 03:57
Forum: Tau Tactics
Topic: 8th Ed Firesight Marksmen (without Sniper Drones)
Replies: 1
Views: 686

Re: 8th Ed Firesight Marksmen (without Sniper Drones)

Wrote about this in the Markerlight Discussion Topic already: With the one Markerlight way, the Firesight Marksman becomes an interesting choice. Being a single character model in the elite slot that gets a +2 safe in cover with 3 wounds makes him a cheap choice that is unlikely to be a main target ...
by Elphiel
Jun 20 2017 04:30
Forum: General Discussion
Topic: 8th Edition - Tidewall Fortifications
Replies: 32
Views: 3190

Re: 8th Edition - Tidewall Fortifications

OK thanks for all your views so far. I tried my little Droneport in two games with a Fireblade for the altogether five 2+ markerlights and also put a minimum squad of Pathfinders with 3 overheating Ion Rifles with them. Distributing single markerlights around the area, also reduces the chance to mel...

Go to advanced search